top of page
Green Hydrocarbons vs Green Hydrogen: D4 RIN close rose from $1.14 to $2.54 between 2 January and 10 July 2026

Green Hydrocarbons vs Green Hydrogen: Portfolio Roles in OBBBA World

Writer: Gaurav Shah
Gaurav Shah
Jun 15
9 min read

Updated: Oct 20

Updated October 2026 with current RIN, LCFS and 45Z values.

Green hydrocarbons versus green hydrogen is usually framed as a contest. The two actually sit at different points in the same value chain, with very different policy support and time to cash. After OBBBA, and with Brent near $127 a barrel on 14 October 2026 (EIA), the allocation question has a clear answer. It turns on the incentive stack.

Two Points in One Value Chain

Green hydrocarbons (renewable diesel, sustainable aviation fuel and synthetic e-fuels) are drop-in molecules. They run in existing engines, pipelines and refineries and sell into markets that already exist. Green hydrogen, for most near-term uses, is an input. It goes into refining, ammonia and the synthesis of those same e-fuels.

Hydrogen sits upstream of the hydrocarbon. The useful question is where in that chain policy and demand actually pay. Today the answer is the molecule that can be sold.

The Incentive Stack: Three Credits Versus One

A green-hydrocarbon producer earns a stack of independent credits. Merchant green hydrogen earns one.

Incentive stack in October 2026: RINs about $3.23 and 45Z about $0.30-0.40 per gallon of renewable diesel, versus 45V up to $3 per kg for merchant green hydrogen

Pathway

45Z

RIN (RFS)

LCFS (state)

Federal stack (45Z + RIN)

Earliest expiry

Renewable diesel ($/gal)

~$0.30-0.40

~$3.23

Extra, varies by CI

~$3.53-3.63

45Z 2029; RFS and LCFS ongoing

SAF ($/gal)

Varies by CI

~$3.04

Extra, varies by CI

~$3.04 plus 45Z

45Z 2029; RFS and LCFS ongoing

Merchant green H2 ($/kg)

None

None

None

Up to $3.00 (45V only)

45V: construction must begin before 1 Jan 2028

RIN values use D4 RINs at $1.90, the 16 October 2026 broker close (Progressive Fuels Limited). Renewable diesel earns 1.7 RINs a gallon in 2026. Renewable jet typically earns about 1.6, calculated from its energy content under 40 CFR 80.1415. Fuel sold in California, Oregon or Washington, which run low-carbon fuel programs, earns all three credits; elsewhere it earns two.

Three points stand out.

The RIN is now the biggest leg. D4 RINs closed at $1.14 on 2 January 2026 and more than doubled by July, closing at $2.54 on 10 July. They have since fallen back, to $1.90 on 16 October (broker closes, Progressive Fuels Limited). Even at that level, the RIN leg alone is worth around $3.23 a gallon of renewable diesel.

D4 RIN prices in 2026: $1.14 on 2 January, $2.54 on 10 July, $1.90 on 16 October

That size cuts both ways. If D4 fell back to $1.14, where it started 2026, the renewable diesel RIN leg would drop to about $1.94, a loss of about $1.30 a gallon, and RINs fell 64 cents between July and mid-October alone. The multiplier also shrinks next year: from 1 January 2027, EPA's final RFS rule cuts renewable diesel's equivalence value from 1.7 to 1.5 RINs a gallon unless a producer qualifies for more. At $1.90 a RIN, that alone takes the renewable diesel RIN leg from about $3.23 to about $2.85 a gallon.

The 45Z credit is smaller than its headline, and feedstock origin decides whether it applies. The 2026 ceiling is $1.09 a gallon, and only for producers that meet wage and apprenticeship requirements; the rest get 22 cents. The actual credit is that amount multiplied by an emissions factor, (50 minus the fuel's carbon intensity) divided by 50, and renewable diesel producers were earning roughly 30 to 40 cents a gallon in early 2026 (Crux). For fuel produced after 31 December 2025, the feedstock must also be produced or grown in the US, Canada or Mexico (IRS Notice 2026-53). Fuel made from used cooking oil or tallow imported from elsewhere earns no 45Z at all. It still earns RINs, but EPA intends to cut the RIN value of imported feedstock from 2028 or shortly after.

LCFS adds a state layer. In California, LCFS credits traded near $90 a tonne in mid-October 2026, under amendments that took effect on 1 July 2025. The per-gallon value depends on each fuel's carbon intensity, so it sits outside the federal total.

Merchant green hydrogen has one credit. The 45V Clean Hydrogen Production Credit, up to $3 a kilogram, is its entire support. There is no RIN, no LCFS and no blending mandate pulling merchant hydrogen into a market at a premium. That asymmetry is the portfolio argument.

The Policy Runway Under OBBBA

OBBBA changed the runways as well as the levels, and it did so unevenly. The 45V hydrogen credit now requires projects to begin construction before 1 January 2028, the shortest runway of any clean-fuel incentive. The 45Z clean-fuel credit covers fuel sold through 2029. The RFS and California's LCFS are ongoing programs. OBBBA also gave the 45Q carbon capture credit, which underpins blue hydrogen, the same value for utilization as for storage.

The policy gradient runs away from merchant green hydrogen and toward liquids and carbon capture.

Policy runway: 45V construction deadline 1 Jan 2028, 45Z through 2029, RFS, LCFS and 45Q ongoing

SAF Lost Its Federal Premium

OBBBA removed the SAF premium in 45Z. SAF produced from 2026 gets the same ceiling as other fuels, $1.09 a gallon in 2026, against $1.91 for SAF produced in 2025, and it faces the same North American feedstock rule. Federal credit support now tilts toward road renewable diesel, even as Europe's ReFuelEU mandate pulls the other way.

SAF's US economics therefore lean on the RIN and LCFS legs and on the European premium far more than on 45Z. In 2026, renewable diesel also earns slightly more RINs per gallon than SAF (1.7 against about 1.6). That edge narrows or reverses in 2027, when EPA's default for renewable diesel falls to 1.5.

The Green Hydrogen Graveyard: What the Cancellations Teach

The merchant-hydrogen thesis was tested in the market in 2025, and it largely failed. Close to 60 major clean-hydrogen projects, about 4.9 million tonnes a year of planned capacity, were cancelled in 2025 (S&P Global). The IEA says projects that have reached a final investment decision make up only about 9% of the pipeline to 2030.

Viability gap: about 9% of announced low-emissions hydrogen production to 2030 has reached final investment decision

Each named case carries a lesson for underwriting:

What happened (2025)

The lesson for underwriting

Fortescue cancelled its Arizona and Gladstone PEM50 projects in July 2025, after final investment decision. It cited the US policy shift for Arizona and a move away from its own PEM technology for Gladstone.

A final investment decision does not end duration risk. Policy and technology bets can still unwind after sanction.

Air Products took a charge of up to $3.1bn in February 2025 and exited three US projects, including Massena, New York, after rule changes made its existing hydropower supply ineligible for 45V.

A project whose economics hang on a single eligibility ruling is one ruling away from a write-down.

BP exited the Duqm green hydrogen project in Oman in December 2025, after leaving the A$55bn (about US$36bn) Australian Renewable Energy Hub in July 2025.

Large projects without a buyer are the first cut when capital tightens.

Nikola filed for Chapter 11 in February 2025. Its assets were auctioned in August, and its workforce later fell from 874 to one.

A hydrogen demand story with no profitable end market is a cash-burn story. Underwrite the offtake.

Five failure modes recur across these cases:

  1. No bankable offtake. Buyers will not sign the 10- to 20-year, billion-dollar commitments producers need.

  2. A viability gap. Production cost runs far above what end users will pay, and unlike renewable diesel or SAF, no mandate closes the gap.

  3. Electrolyzer costs that never fell as promised. Each plant is still bespoke, and the learning curve has not arrived.

  4. Missing shared infrastructure. Hydrogen and CO2 pipelines are shelved for want of committed volume.

  5. Single-credit dependence. One policy change ends the project.

A green-hydrocarbon producer selling a drop-in fuel into a mandated, oil-linked market with a multi-credit stack has already retired most of these risks.

The hydrogen projects still moving share a profile: each has a contracted buyer, often as part of an e-fuel or a single industrial user. The merchant pure play, a molecule with no contracted home, is what fills the graveyard. The lesson concerns where in the chain to take the risk, and hydrogen still has a place in it.

Where Hydrogen Pays: Inside a Finished Fuel

Because merchant hydrogen has no demand pull and a 2028 construction deadline, its strongest near-term case is as a captive input to a green hydrocarbon. Feed green hydrogen and captured CO2 into an e-fuel, such as e-SAF or e-diesel, and the hydrogen's value is captured through the finished fuel's incentive stack: the RIN, LCFS and 45Z legs that merchant hydrogen cannot touch, plus the oil-linked price of the liquid. With D4 RINs near $1.90, the RIN leg of that stack is worth about two-thirds more than it was at the start of 2026.

Used this way, hydrogen becomes a margin input to a molecule that already has a buyer. In an OBBBA world, investors capture hydrogen value inside hydrocarbons.

The Portfolio Scorecard

Dimension

Green hydrocarbons

Merchant green H2

Existing infrastructure / drop-in

5

2

Demand certainty (mandates)

5

2

Incentive-stack depth

5

2

Policy durability under OBBBA

4

2

Oil-price tailwind (high Brent in 2026)

5

2

Time to cash

5

2

Long-duration scale optionality

3

5

Total (of 35)

32

17

Hydrocarbons win every near-term dimension. Hydrogen wins one: long-duration scale optionality. In the 2040s, when easy liquid feedstocks run short and deep decarbonization needs molecules made from CO2 and water, hydrogen becomes the backbone. Even then, its value is best captured inside an e-fuel.

How We'd Allocate

Weight the near-term book to green hydrocarbons: drop-in renewable diesel and, selectively, SAF, where the credit stack and the oil-linked price are doing the work and the cash is real today. Treat the credit stack as the asset and the fuel as the by-product, and underwrite each leg on its own. With RINs now the largest leg, the main stress case is a further fall in RIN prices, which have already dropped about 25% from their July high. The 45Z runway ending in 2029 is the second.

Hold green hydrogen as a long-duration option. Capture it where it pays: embedded in e-fuels with a route to the hydrocarbon stack, or as the input to a hard-to-abate industrial buyer with a real contract. Avoid the merchant pure play whose whole case is a single credit with a 2028 construction deadline.

What Clears an Investment Committee

  1. Map the full incentive stack and its expiry. Which credits (45Z, RIN, LCFS, 45V, 45Q), what value, what runway. The stack sets the margin.

  2. Stress each credit leg on its own. Test a RIN price back near early-2026 levels, the 2027 cut to 1.5 RINs a gallon for renewable diesel, 45Z ending after 2029 and an LCFS amendment. If the project only clears with every leg intact, it is fragile.

  3. For hydrogen, find the demand pull. Is it embedded in an e-fuel or contracted to a creditworthy industrial buyer? A merchant molecule with no mandate is an orphan.

  4. Price the oil linkage. Hydrocarbons gain when crude is high and lose when it falls. Size positions with that in mind while Brent stays high.

  5. Run the project against the five failure modes. If it trips two, it does not belong in the book.

  6. Separate 2026 cash from the 2040s option. Do not pay a growth multiple for a near-term cash asset, or underwrite a long-duration option at today's hurdle rate.

Hydrocarbons vs Hydrogen: Investor FAQ

Are green hydrocarbons or green hydrogen the better investment under OBBBA?

For near-term cash, green hydrocarbons. They stack independent credits, use existing infrastructure and sell into mandated demand. Merchant green hydrogen relies on one credit, 45V, with a 2028 construction deadline.

What is the incentive stack for renewable diesel and SAF?

At October 2026 prices, RINs are the largest leg: about $3.23 a gallon for renewable diesel and about $3.04 for SAF, with D4 RINs at $1.90. The renewable diesel figure falls to about $2.85 in 2027, when its default equivalence value drops from 1.7 to 1.5 RINs a gallon. The 45Z credit adds roughly 30 to 40 cents a gallon for renewable diesel, and California LCFS credits add more depending on carbon intensity.

How did OBBBA change the 45V hydrogen credit?

Projects must now begin construction before 1 January 2028, the shortest runway of any clean-fuel incentive.

Did 45Z reduce support for SAF?

Yes. OBBBA removed the SAF premium, so SAF produced from 2026 gets the same 45Z ceiling as other fuels, $1.09 a gallon in 2026, against $1.91 for SAF produced in 2025.

Does imported used cooking oil still earn the 45Z credit?

Not from outside North America. Fuel produced after 31 December 2025 qualifies only if its feedstock was produced or grown in the US, Canada or Mexico, so imported used cooking oil and tallow from elsewhere earn no 45Z. They still earn RINs, but EPA intends to reduce the RIN value of imported feedstock from 2028 or shortly after.

Where does green hydrogen make money today?

Inside a finished fuel, such as e-SAF or e-diesel, where it earns through that fuel's credit stack, or under contract to a hard-to-abate industrial buyer.

Why were so many green hydrogen projects cancelled in 2025?

Close to 60 major projects, about 4.9 Mtpa, were cancelled in 2025 (S&P Global). The main causes were no bankable offtake, high production costs with no mandate to cover them, and dependence on a single credit.

Methodology: incentive values are October 2026 reference points (D4 RIN $1.90 on 16 October; California LCFS about $90/t; 45Z ceiling $1.09/gal in 2026, about $0.30-0.40/gal earned by renewable diesel; 45V up to $3/kg) and move with markets and guidance. Portfolio scores are Trident's framework. Sources: Progressive Fuels Limited weekly RIN recaps, EIA and Fastmarkets (RINs); EIA via FRED (Brent); 40 CFR 80.1415 (RIN equivalence values); Fuse and Progressive Fuels Limited (LCFS); Crux, IRS Notices 2026-41 and 2026-53 (45Z); EPA RFS final rule, April 2026 (2027 equivalence values and import RIN plans); S&P Global and IEA Global Hydrogen Review 2025 (project cancellations and FIDs); company announcements and trade press (named cases). Analysis, not investment advice.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page